What would actually
happen, however, if animal husbandry were abandoned in favor of mass
agriculture, brought about by humanity turning towards vegetarianism?
If a large number of
people switched to vegetarianism, the demand for meat in the United States and
Europe would fall, the supply of grain would dramatically increase, but the
buying power of poor [starving] people in Africa and Asia wouldn’t change at
all.
The result would be very predictable — there would be a
mass exodus from farming. Whereas today the total amount of grains produced
could feed 10 billion people, the total amount of grain grown in this post-meat
world would likely fall back to about 7 or 8 billion. The trend of farmers
selling their land to developers and others would accelerate quickly. (4)
In other words, there
would be less food available for the world to eat. Furthermore, the monoculture
of grains and legumes, which is what would happen if animal husbandry were
abandoned and the world relied exclusively on plant foods for its food, would
rapidly deplete the soil and require the heavy use of artificial fertilizers,
one ton of which requires ten tons of crude oil to produce (5).
As far as the impact to
our environment, a closer look reveals the great damage that exclusive and mass
farming would do. British organic dairy farmer and researcher Mark Purdey
wisely points out that if “veganic agricultural systems were to gain a foothold
on the soil, then agrochemical use, soil erosion, cash cropping, prairie-scapes
and ill health would escalate.” (6)
Neanderthin author Ray Audette
concurs with this view:
Since ancient times, the most destructive factor in the
degradation of the environment has been monoculture agriculture. The production
of wheat in ancient Sumeria transformed once-fertile plains into salt flats
that remain sterile 5,000 years later. As well as depleting both the soil and
water sources, monoculture agriculture also produces environmental damage by
altering the delicate balance of natural ecosystems. World rice production in
1993, for instance, caused 155 million cases of malaria by providing breeding
grounds for mosquitoes in the paddies. Human contact with ducks in the same
rice paddies resulted in 500 million cases of influenza during the same year.(7)
There is little doubt,
though, that commercial farming methods, whether of plants or animals produce
harm to the environment. With the heavy use of agrochemicals, pesticides,
artificial fertilizers, hormones, steroids, and antibiotics common in modern
agriculture, a better way of integrating animal husbandry with agriculture
needs to be found. A possible solution might be a return to “mixed farming,”
described below.
The educated consumer and
the enlightened farmer together can bring about a return of the mixed farm,
where cultivation of fruits, vegetables and grains is combined with the raising
of livestock and fowl in a manner that is efficient, economical and
environmentally friendly. For example, chickens running free in garden areas
eat insect pests, while providing high-quality eggs; sheep grazing in orchards
obviate the need for herbicides; and cows grazing in woodlands and other
marginal areas provide rich, pure milk, making these lands economically viable
for the farmer. It is not animal cultivation that leads to hunger and famine,
but unwise agricultural practices and monopolistic distribution systems. (8)
The “mixed farm” is also
healthier for the soil, which will yield more crops if managed according to
traditional guidelines. Mark Purdey has accurately pointed out that a crop
field on a mixed farm will yield up to five harvests a year, while a
“mono-cropped” one will only yield one or two (9). Which farm is producing more
food for the world’s peoples? Purdey well sums up the ecological horrors of
“battery farming” and points to future solutions by saying:
Our agricultural establishments could do very well to
outlaw the business-besotted farmers running intensive livestock units, battery
systems and beef-burger bureaucracies; with all their wastages, deplorable
cruelty, anti-ozone slurry systems; drug/chemical induced immunotoxicity
resulting in B.S.E. [see myth # 13] and salmonella, rain forest eradication,
etc. Our future direction must strike the happy, healthy medium of mixed farms,
resurrecting the old traditional extensive system as a basic framework, then
bolstering up productivity to present day demands by incorporating a more
updated application of biological science into farming systems. (10)
It does not appear, then,
that livestock farming, when properly practiced, damages the environment. Nor
does it appear that world vegetarianism or exclusively relying on agriculture
to supply the world with food are feasible or ecologically wise ideas.