Introduction The US Dietary Guidelines Advisory Committee (DGAC), in its 2015 Scientific Report(1)proposed to remove the limit on the total consumption of fat but left the recommended limit on saturated fats (SFA) consumption at less than 10% of total daily calories, citing a list of research papers. Similar recommendations are stipulated by the World Health Organization (2) while European agencies propose that SFA intake be as low as possible (3 and references therein). Despite the consensual approach to SFA in the various guidelines there is no scientific consensus regarding the association between SFA consumption and cardiovascular disease (CVD). Harcombe et al. (4)concluded that the evidence from randomized controlled trials, at the time of the introduction of the guidelines in 1977, did not support the limitation of dietary SFA. Lamarche and Couture (3) published a review of the role of dietary SFA in CVD, calling for a review of the guidelines due to a lack of convincing evidence associating the two. A recent meta-analysis by Chowdhury, Warnakula (5) found that "Current evidence does not clearly support cardiovascular guidelines that encourage high consumption of polyunsaturated fatty acids and low consumption of total saturated fats", a conclusion that drew a number ofopposing letters(e.g. 6). Recently a Cochran report (7)found, based on meta-analysis, a small but potentially important reduction in cardiovascular risk on reduction of saturated fat intake. The Guidelines Advisory Committee, in its 2015 Scientific Report referred to animal fat when guiding the public to reduce consumption of SFA (1), demonstrating a common perception, which often appears in dietary guidelines, that identify saturated fat with animal fat. The identification of SFA with animal fat can also be found in academia. Ahrens had already noted in 1957 (8)that the distinction between animal and vegetable fat is chemically meaningless and even misleading. Nonetheless the Cochran report cited above (7), contains a study of the effect of animal fat consumption which is treated in the Cochran report as SFA. In several terrestrial animals studied by Cordain et al. (9), SFA as a percentage of fats ranges from 19% in marrow through 30-41% in muscle to 66% in subcutaneous fat. A review of information on the Nutritiondata website (http://nutritiondata.self.com/) reveals a high variation in SFA content among various types of foods and source animals. For example, beef steak contains 39% SFA, bacon 31.4%, pork leg (ham) 34.7% , cow milk being the only one to contain more than half (58%) of the fats as SFA. Theoretically then, one can consume 30% of the daily calories as bacon and still be within the 10% guidelines for SFA. This study reviews the symbolic usage of animal fat by traditional societies in an attempt to identify their perception in regard to its healthfulness. The first significant contribution of a deep historical perspective to the question of healthy diets was arguably made by Eaton and Konner (10), comparing the present diet to a typical Paleolithic diet. Their paper presented a paradigm that minimizing the mismatch between present and past, evolutionary adapted, diets will be conducive to health. Later, Cordain et al. (11) used ethnographic data to calculate the macronutrients composition of hunter-gatherers’ diets, estimating a range of 28-58% of energy derived from fat on average, and 43-58% from fat in societies above 40 ̊ N or S latitude. Cordain (12) estimated that SFA consumption in pre-agricultural societies constituted 10-15%of energy intake. Sometimes the relevance of past societies' dietary patterns to present conditions is rejected with the claim that people in these societies did not live long enough to manifest typical western noncommunicative diseases like CVD. Demographic data (13)shows, however, that in hunter-gatherer societies "Survivorship to grandparental age is achieved by over two-thirds of people who reach 1 Ben-Dor: Animal Fat as Symbol of Fertility and Health in Traditional Societies Published by Journal of Evolution and Health, 2013 2 sexual maturity and can last an average of 20 years". A mortality hazard factor in hunter-gatherers that is 75 to190 times higher at the ages of 0-15 years, compared to present Western societies(13),makes the comparison of life expectancy at birth, which is the often cited difference between traditional and Western societies, inappropriate. Most researchers agree that humans consumed significant amounts of animal meat and fat throughout their evolution(e.g. 14). Humans are able to process a maximum of about 35% of their energetic requirements from protein (15) which means that the remaining 65% has to come from carbohydrates and fat, mostly from animals. Depending on ecological conditions, fat could compose up to 60% and more of the caloric content of animals that human used to hunt (16) which means that humans consumed significant amounts of animal fat throughout their evolution. Although a limited availability of carbohydrates is hard to imagine in our agricultural-industrial era, it is quite likely that during the Paleolithic, under cold or dry climatic conditions, availability of plant food may have been limited and energetically expensive to gather and process (17). Under such circumstances, a physiological requirement of a substantial quantity of animal fat (up to 65% of daily calories) is bound to have existed and had likely played a significant role in major aspects of human behavior such as hunting (16) and mobility (18). Indeed several patterns in the archaeological faunal record can be interpreted as stemming from the desire to hunt fat animals and maximize fat exploitation from acquired animals. In the face of archaeological evidence for seasonality in hunting of certain animals, Speth (19) came to the conclusion that: " …fat, not protein, seemed to play a very prominent role in the hunters’ decisions about what animals (male vs. female) to kill and which body parts to discard or take away”. Archaeological evidence for the supremacy of fat in Paleolithic humans’ hunting considerations can be deduced from the atypical predatory behavior of humans of preferring to hunt prime-adult animals over, the more vulnerable and easily obtained, young or old animals (19-21). We have argued (16) that such a hunting strategy makes sense because male and female prime adults contain a higher percentage of body fat than young or old animals during the year. Fat essentiality can also explain the apparent human preference of obtaining large game (e.g. 21), as large game contains almost double the percentage of calories from fat compared to small game(16). Also, large animals conserve more of their fat in times of nutritional distress, like dry summers and snowy winters (22) when plant food for both animals and humans is scarce. Another archaeological pattern which points to intensive utilization of animal fat is the extraction of bone marrow as evidenced by prey body parts that were preferably brought to the consumption site and by their bone breakage pattern(eg. 21, 23, 24, 25). Finally, in agreement with ethnographic evidence (26) there is archaeological evidence for a very laborious process of extraction of fat from animal bones, without the benefit of fire-proof cooking vessels, in widespread ecological settings(27-31). There is ample ethnographic evidence for human dependence on and preference for animal fat as a food source. Kelly (32) writes: “…although ethnographic accounts abound with references to the importance of meat they equally convey the importance of fat…”. He adds: “It therefore may be fat rather than protein that drives the desire for meat in many foraging societies”. Lee (33) writes about the !Kung of the Kalahari: “Fat animals are keenly desired, and all !Kung express a constant craving for animal fat”. About the James Bay Cree, Rockwell (34) writes: “The Cree considered fat the most important part of any animal. One reason they valued bears above other animals was because of their body fat and because the fat rendered down into a high quality 2 Journal of Evolution and Health, Vol. 1 [2013], Iss. 1, Art. 10 http://jevohealth.com/journal/vol1/iss1/10 DOI: 10.15310/2334-3591.1022 3 grease”. The essentiality of fat is best demonstrated in Tindale’s account of the Pitjandjara of Australia (35). He writes: "When killing the animal they immediately feel the body for evidence of the presence of caul fat. If the animal is njuka, fatless, it is usually left unless they are themselves starving”. Coote and Shelton (36) report a similar attitude among the Yolngu of Arnhem, Australia, saying that "Animals without fat may indeed be rejected as food". In summary, ethnographic evidence corroborates archaeological evidence of the prominent role of animal fat in human nutrition and behavior. . The purpose of this paper is to contribute a historic qualitative point of view to published estimates and ethnographers' accounts of the importance of animal fat, and by reference to SFA, by researching patterns in the contexts of symbolic use of animal fat and the term "fat" in diverse cultural and environmental settings. To the extent that such corroborations exist, they will strengthen the validity of the claim that humans are evolutionarily adapted to consume significant quantities of animal fat and by reference, saturated fats
The immediate question that comes to mind is how a substance that had been consumed by humans in significant quantities during their evolution and which was so universally desired and so universally perceived as associated with life, fertility, nourishment and healing to the extent that it was perceived as sacred in traditional societies, becomes a health risk in nutritional guidelines the world over. As described in the introduction, contrary to common perception, the continuous denouncement of animal fat and of SFA in the dietary guidelines by the USDA was never accompanied by a clear scientific consensus. Two books by science journalists – Good Calories Bad Calories by Taubes (46) and Big Fat Surprise by Teicholtz (47) describe the historical events that lead to the seminal publication of "Dietary Guidelines for Americans" by the USDA in 1977. Both came to the conclusion that the scientific evidence that led to the guidelines’ recommendation to limit fat was and still is extremely weak and controversial. Prominent nutrition scientists disagree (e.g. 6, 48) and the debate continues (49). A detailed review of the controversy is beyond the scope of this paper. However, it is impossible to ignore the blatant contradiction between the extremely positive attitudes towards animal fat as are 7 Ben-Dor: Animal Fat as Symbol of Fertility and Health in Traditional Societies Published by Journal of Evolution and Health, 2013 8 reflected in the symbolic expressions and hunting behavior of prehistoric and recent traditional populations, and the negative perception among some health professionals and scientists, as it is reflected in the present public health organizations' dietary guidelines. This discrepancy begs a resolution, either by scientific explanation or by a suitable change in the guidelines.